Why this Matters
-
An extravagant ruling by NY courts empowered a minority of vulture funds with a weapon to sabotage sovereign debt restructurings by allowing them to block 92.4% of Argentina’s creditors from collecting.
-
The legal precedent set by NY courts has given unprecedented leverage to holdout vulture funds to abuse sovereigns, good faith creditors, financial institutions and the global financial system.
-
Unsustainable debts are an obstacle to sustainable human development and, thus a serious impediment to the realization of all human rights.
-
The rulings by NY courts in the case of Argentina’s sovereign debt restructuring have forever changed sovereign debt markets, rendering future sovereign debt restructurings virtually impossible.
-
The extravagant rulings in the Argentine sovereign debt restructuring case have systemic implications that jeopardize stability and predictability of international financial markets.
-
Because of an erroneous interpretation of a common clause found in most sovereign debt bonds around the world, the NY rulings stand against US and international creditors and threaten the preeminence of NY as a global financial center.
Documents about Why this Matters
Argentina`s Sovereign bondage
Anne Krueger
Anne Krueger
How could Greece and Argentina—the new ‘debt colonies’—be set free?
Ha-Joon Chang
Ha-Joon Chang
Sovereign debt needs international supervision
Joseph Stiglitz
Joseph Stiglitz
Doble default
Zachary Karabell
Zachary Karabell
Gouging the Gauchos
Nouriel Roubini
Nouriel Roubini
Implications of the US Supreme Court ruling on Argentina
José Antonio Ocampo
José Antonio Ocampo
Argentina’s ‘vulture fund’ crisis threatens profound consequences for international financial system
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD)
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD)
Hedge Fund v. Sovereign: How U.S. Courts are upending international finance
Felix Salmon
Felix Salmon
Transcript of a Press Briefing by Gerry Rice, Director, Communications Department, International Monetary Fund
International Monetary Fund (IMF)
International Monetary Fund (IMF)
Why eurozone should monitor US Supreme Court decision on Argentina
Linda Yueh
Linda Yueh
Argentina’s rational default
Dan Rosenheck
Dan Rosenheck
Vulture funds impede all debt restructuring
Joseph Stiglitz
Joseph Stiglitz
Argentina is right to stand up to greedy US vultures
Sarah-Jayne Clifton
Sarah-Jayne Clifton
Strengthening the contractual framework to address collective action problemas in sovereign debt restructuring
International Monetary Fund (IMF)
International Monetary Fund (IMF)
Waters Calls for New International Financial Architecture
Maxine Waters
Maxine Waters
Annual Report 2014
International Monetary Fund (IMF)
International Monetary Fund (IMF)
A Costly, Lose-Lose Situation for Argentina and the Holdouts
Eduardo Levy Yeyati
Eduardo Levy Yeyati
Transcript of a Press Roundtable with IMF Managing Director Christine Lagarde
Christine Lagarde
Christine Lagarde
Argentina’s bondholders deserve their day in court
José Antonio Ocampo
Aldo Caliari
José Antonio Ocampo
Aldo Caliari
Who shot Argentina: a washington murder mistery
Mark Weisbrot
Mark Weisbrot
From Argentina to Greece: Crisis in the Global architecture of orderly sovereign debt restructurings
Nouriel Roubini
Nouriel Roubini
G77 Declaration addresses “global challenges”
Martin Khor
Martin Khor
Debeaking the vultures
Joseph Stiglitz
Joseph Stiglitz
The Debt Vultures’ Fell Swoop
Mark Weisbrot
Mark Weisbrot
Argentina default? Griesafault is much more accurate
Joseph Stiglitz
Joseph Stiglitz
Vultures’ victory
Joseph Stiglitz
Joseph Stiglitz
After Argentina
Anna Gelpern
Anna Gelpern
Argentina will survive default but indebted nations in Africa will not be so lucky
John Weeks
John Weeks
Close
Vulture Funds
-
Vulture funds are hedge funds specialized in buying distressed debt in the secondary markets for pennies on the dollar with the sole purpose of litigating for the full repayment plus interest.
-
Vulture funds do not lend money. They abuse legal systems around the world in order to get extraordinary profits at the expense of countries, people, and the overwhelming majority of creditors.
-
Vulture funds are marginal actors of the financial system. Their predatory practices create more vulnerable, unfair and uncertain global financial markets.
-
Vulture funds exploit the absence of a sovereign bankruptcy regime. The global community, including the United Nations, the International Monetary Fund, the G20 and the International Capital Markets Association, among others, has warned about their predatory practices and is working on solutions to stop them.
-
Vulture funds are based in tax havens to avoid paying taxes in their home countries.
-
Vulture funds have targeted numerous sovereigns across all regions of the world, and are likely to continue to do so in the future, if actions are not taken. In the Argentine case, they bought debt many years after the default and sued for an unprecedented 1600% profit. They have spent millions of dollars in lobbying and PR campaigns against Argentina.
Documents about Vulture Funds
Special statement by the Member States of MERCOSUR in support of the Argentine Republic and in defense of its sovereign debt restructuring
Mercosur
Mercosur
Sovereign debt for territory: A new global elite swap strategy
Adrian Salbuchi
Adrian Salbuchi
Sovereign Debt Workouts: Going Forward. Roadmap and Guide
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD)
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD)
Early Motion 666—UK Parliament
UK Parliamentarians
UK Parliamentarians
A short Story of vultures
Saskia Sassen
Saskia Sassen
Letter of the President of Egypt to President Cristina Fernández de Kirchner
Abdel Fattah el-Sisi
Abdel Fattah el-Sisi
Workers of the Americas against vulture funds
Education Internacional
Education Internacional
Parlasur approved declaration against the vulture funds
Mercosur Parliament
Mercosur Parliament
Belgium Parliament: law on foreign states immunities against vulture funds
Belgium Parliament
Belgium Parliament
Special Communiqué on the new international capitalism`s attack against the Argentine Republic through vultures funds
ALBA-TCP
ALBA-TCP
Debeaking the vultures
Joseph Stiglitz
Joseph Stiglitz
Ministerial Declaration adopted by the 37th Annual Meeting of Ministers for Foreign Affairs of the Group of 77 and China
G77 + China
G77 + China
World Bank to Increase Support to Curb Vulture Fund Actions
Danny Leipziger
Danny Leipziger
Declaration in support of Argentina regarding the ruling on the NML Capital Ltd. vs. Republic of Argentina
G77 + China
G77 + China
Special Declaration of Support for the position of the Argentine Republic with respect to the restructuring of its sovereign debt
Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC)
Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC)
How Barack Obama could end the Argentina debt crisis
Greg Palast
Greg Palast
Special statement by the Member States of MERCOSUR in support of the Argentine Republic
Mercosur
Mercosur
Holdouts give vultures a bad name
Martin Wolf
Martin Wolf
G77 Declaration addresses “global challenges”
Martin Khor
Martin Khor
Brazil supported Argentina against vulture funds
Antonio Patriota
Antonio Patriota
Mexican Ambassador to the Argentine Republic supports the country against vulture funds
Fernando Castro Trenti
Fernando Castro Trenti
Doble default
Zachary Karabell
Zachary Karabell
Declaration of the Council of the Socialist International on Argentina
Socialist International
Socialist International
Bank of the South rejects vulture fund’s actions
Bank of the South, Administrative Council
Bank of the South, Administrative Council
Modalities for the implementation of resolution 68/304, entitled “Towards the establishment of a multilateral legal framework for sovereign debt restructuring processes”
United Nations
United Nations
No vulture left behind
Jorge Vilches
Jorge Vilches
The Rise of the Holdouts: Disrupting Sovereign Debt Restructuring
Samuel George
Samuel George
The Vultures of Wall Street
Saskia Sassen
Saskia Sassen
Press Release “We have to fight against the irregular activities of vulture funds”
Clintonians Join Vulture Flock Over Argentina
Conn Hallinan
Conn Hallinan
Belgium Parliament: law “against the activities of vulture funds”
Belgium Parliament
Belgium Parliament
A Global System is needed for debt restructuring
Joseph Stiglitz
Joseph Stiglitz
Latin American Parliament supports Argentina’s position in dispute with vulture funds
Latin American Parliament
Latin American Parliament
Africa-South America Cooperation Forum, Malabo Statement, III ASA Summit, Malabo, equatorial Guinea
Africa-South America Summit (ASA)
Africa-South America Summit (ASA)
Resolution of ALADI in support for the position of Argentina regarding their sovereign debt restructuring
Latin American Integration Association (ALADI)
Latin American Integration Association (ALADI)
Mujica: “Vulture funds want to eat Argentina’s oil”
José Mujica
José Mujica
Bill regarding the fight against the activities of vulture funds
Belgium Parliament
Belgium Parliament
GUE/NGL MEPs express solidarity with Argentina in its battle with criminal speculators
Confederal Group of the European United Left/Nordic Green Left (GUE/NGL)
Confederal Group of the European United Left/Nordic Green Left (GUE/NGL)
Defend Argentina from the vultures
Martin Wolf
Martin Wolf
Close
Argentina’s proposal
-
Argentina wants to find a solution for 100% of its creditors under fair, equitable, sustainable and legal conditions.
-
Argentina has a fair and reasonable offer already on the table that would end this litigation: holdouts can join the debt exchange under the conditions accepted by 92.4% of the bondholders.
-
By accepting Argentina’s offer, the vulture funds would obtain a profit of more than 300%.
-
Argentina cannot accept the vulture funds’ extortion. Vulture funds are holding the 92.4% of creditors hostage and demanding a 1600% profit for their release. This position is unreasonable and is a direct threat to the stability and predictability of the global financial system.
-
Looking forward: while the contractual approach of improved collective action clauses is a positive step, it remains insufficient since there are no fully “vulture proof” clauses. The international community needs to come together to establish a multilateral legal framework for sovereign debt restructuring processes. This process is already underway at the United Nations.
Close
Support Of Argentina’s Position
Order of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissing plaintiffs´ Third Amended Complaint regarding alter ego allegations of Argentina´s central bank
United States District Court for the Southern District of New York
United States District Court for the Southern District of New York
Puricelli v. Republic of Argentina (case 14-2104-cv (L)) Appeal from United States District Court for the Southern District of New York
United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
Clintonians Join Vulture Flock Over Argentina
Conn Hallinan
Conn Hallinan
Brussels Declaration “Shaping our common future: working together for prosperous, cohesive and sustainable societies for our citizens”
EU-CELAC
EU-CELAC
Towards a Multilateral Framework for Recovery from Sovereign Insolvency
Barry Herman
Barry Herman
Sovereign Debt Workouts: Going Forward. Roadmap and Guide
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD)
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD)
Where the Argentine Debt case Stands Now, and Why it still matters
Aldo Caliari
Aldo Caliari
Attack of vulture funds against Argentina—The dead can not repay their debts
Jacques Cheminade
Jacques Cheminade
In Argentina Debt Case, a Great Victory for Speculators
Alan B. Cibils
Alan B. Cibils
Brief of Joseph Stiglitz as Amicus Curiae in support of the Republic of Argentina’s petition for a writ of certiorari
Joseph Stiglitz
Joseph Stiglitz
Special Declaration of Support for the position of the Argentine Republic with respect to the restructuring of its sovereign debt
Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC)
Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC)
Did Argentina default?
Jorge Vilches
Jorge Vilches
Joint Communique of Presidents of States Parties to MERCOSUR. XLVII Regular Meeting of the Common Market Council
Mercosur
Mercosur
Special Communique of States Parties to MERCOSUR in support of Argentina
Mercosur
Mercosur
Joint Communiqué of Presidents of States Parties the MERCOSUR and Associate States, XLVII Regular Meeting of the Common Market Council
Mercosur
Mercosur
Special Communique on sovereign debt restructuring
2014 Ibero-American Summit
2014 Ibero-American Summit
Sachs on vulture funds: “It is an abuse US Court ruling”
Jeffrey Sachs
Jeffrey Sachs
G20 Leaders Communiqué – Brisbane Summit
G20
G20
No vulture left behind
Jorge Vilches
Jorge Vilches
Stand with Argentina against the debt vultures
Jubilee Debt UK
Jubilee Debt UK
Debt Ruling Shows a Callous Disregard to the Effects on Argentina
Eileen Appelbaum
Eileen Appelbaum
Latin American Parliament supports Argentina’s position in dispute with vulture funds
Latin American Parliament
Latin American Parliament
Letter of the President of Vietnam to President Cristina Fernández de Kirchner
Truong Tan Sang
Truong Tan Sang
Letter of the President of Egypt to President Cristina Fernández de Kirchner
Abdel Fattah el-Sisi
Abdel Fattah el-Sisi
Economists call on Congress to mitigate fallout from ruling on Argentine debt
Robert Solow
Robert Solow
Special statement by the Member States of MERCOSUR in support of the Argentine Republic and in defense of its sovereign debt restructuring
Mercosur
Mercosur
Communiqué of UNASUR’s Economy and Finance Council
The Union of South American Nations (UNASUR)
The Union of South American Nations (UNASUR)
ECLAC warns that Griesa´s ruling is against the international financial system
ECLAC
ECLAC
The Trial of the Century?
Jorge Vilches
Jorge Vilches
Xi Jinping expressed his “support and understanding” towards Argentina in her “worries about debt”
Xi Jinping
Xi Jinping
Argentina’s Default, Vulture Funds and the US Courts
Jorge Vilches
Jorge Vilches
Declaration G20 Youth Summit
G20 Youth Summit
G20 Youth Summit
Communiqué of the Permanent Secretariat of the Latin American and Caribbean Economic System (SELA) in support of the Argentine Republic’s stance regarding its sovereign debt restructuring process
Latin American and Caribbean Economic System (SELA)
Latin American and Caribbean Economic System (SELA)
Declaration A.N. Nro. 03-2014. Solidarity with Argentine Republic`s position regarding holdouts or vulture funds claim
Nicaragua Parliament
Nicaragua Parliament
Fenix Plan supports the Government and celebrates that Argentina negotiates without fear
Plan Fénix
Plan Fénix
Parlasur approved declaration against the vulture funds
Mercosur Parliament
Mercosur Parliament
Declaration in support for the position of Argentina on its debt sovereign restructuring – Meeting of consultation of Miniters of Foreign Affairs
Organization of American States
Organization of American States
Intervention by Madam Minister of Foreign Affairs of Colombia, María Angela Holguín Cuellar, during the twenty-eight meeting of Consultation of Ministers of Foreign Affairs on Sovereign debt restructuring: the case of Argentina and its systemic consequences
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Colombia
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Colombia
Press Release E-286/14
José Miguel Insulza
José Miguel Insulza
Foreign Ministry Spokesperson Hong Lei’s Regular Press Conference on July 3, 2014
Hong Lei
Hong Lei
Bank of the South rejects vulture fund’s actions
Bank of the South, Administrative Council
Bank of the South, Administrative Council
Secretary-General of the OECD, interview for the French television, “Le grande Journal” of BFM Business
Angel Gurría
Angel Gurría
Statement supporting Argentina in its dispute against hedge funds
Andean Parliament
Andean Parliament
President Maduro ratifies support to Argentina regarding vulture funds
Nicolás Maduro
Nicolás Maduro
Brazil supported Argentina against vulture funds
Antonio Patriota
Antonio Patriota
Resolution of ALADI in support for the position of Argentina regarding their sovereign debt restructuring
Latin American Integration Association (ALADI)
Latin American Integration Association (ALADI)
Statement of Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Cuba in support of Argentina
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Cuba
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Cuba
ECLAC Refers to the Implications of the Holdouts for the International Financial System
Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC)
Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC)
Venezuela rejects vulture fund´s adverse judgment against Argentina
Nicolás Maduro
Nicolás Maduro
Special Communiqué on the new international capitalism`s attack against the Argentine Republic through vultures funds
ALBA-TCP
ALBA-TCP
Declaration of The Council of Heads of State of UNASUR supporting Argentina’s position on the restructuring of its sovereign debt
The Union of South American Nations (UNASUR)
The Union of South American Nations (UNASUR)
Rafael Correa: Argentina should not pay vulture funds
Rafael Correa
Rafael Correa
Mujica: “Vulture funds want to eat Argentina’s oil”
José Mujica
José Mujica
Evo Morales expresses his solidarity with Argentina in the dispute against vulture funds
Evo Morales
Evo Morales
Special statement by the Member States of MERCOSUR in support of the Argentine Republic
Mercosur
Mercosur
CELAC communiqué in support of Argentina’s position regarding its sovereign debt restructuring process
Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC)
Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC)
Early Day Motion 133—UK Parliament
UK Parliamentarians
UK Parliamentarians
Communiqué of the Intergovernmental Group of Twenty-Four on International Monetary Affairs and Development
G24
G24
Brief of Amicus Curiae in support of the Republic of Argentina’s petition for writ of certiorari
Argentine-American Chamber of Commerce (AACC)
Puente Hnos
Argentine-American Chamber of Commerce (AACC)
Puente Hnos
Brief for the United Mexican States as Amicus Curiae in support of the Republic of Argentina´s petition for writs of certiorari submitted before the US Supreme Court
Mexico
Mexico
BRIEF FOR JUBILEE USA NETWORK AS AMICI CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONERS
Jubilee USA Network
Jubilee USA Network
Brief for the Republic of France as Amicus Curiae in support of the Republic of Argentina’s petition for a writ of certiorari submitted before the US Supreme Court
France
France
Brief of Respondent Fintech Advisory Inc. in support of petitioners
Fintech Advisory Inc.
Fintech Advisory Inc.
Brief for Euroclear Bank SA NV as Amicus Curiae in support of the Republic of Argentina’s petition for a writ of certiorari
Euroclear Bank
Euroclear Bank
Brief of Respondents Euro Bondholders in support of petition for writ of certiorari
Euro Bondholders
Euro Bondholders
Brief of Amicus Curiae Caja de Valores in support of petitioner
Caja de Valores
Caja de Valores
Brief of the Federative Republic of Brazil as Amicus Curiae in support of the Republic of Argentina’s petition for a writ of certiorari submitted before the US Supreme Court
Brazil
Brazil
Declaration adopted by the II Summit of CELAC
Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC)
Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (CELAC)
President of Chile Highlights Importance of Multilateralism and Role of the OAS in the Hemisphere
Michelle Bachelet
Michelle Bachelet
Waters Calls for New International Financial Architecture
Maxine Waters
Maxine Waters
Brief for the Republic of France as Amicus Curiae in support of the Republic of Argentina’s petition for a writ of certiorari submitted before the US Supreme Court
France
France
Early Motion 666—UK Parliament
UK Parliamentarians
UK Parliamentarians
Brief for Amicus Curiae the Clearing House Association LLC in support of reversal
Clearing House Association
Clearing House Association
Africa-South America Cooperation Forum, Malabo Statement, III ASA Summit, Malabo, equatorial Guinea
Africa-South America Summit (ASA)
Africa-South America Summit (ASA)
Brief for Professor Anne Krueger as Amicus Curiae in Support of the Republic of Argentina and reversal
Anne Krueger
Anne Krueger
Brief of the American Bankers Association as Amicus Curiae supporting non party the Bank of New York Mellon
American Bank Association (ABA)
American Bank Association (ABA)
Brief for non-party appelant
Fintech Advisory Inc.
Fintech Advisory Inc.
Brief for non-party appelants Exchange Bondholder Group
Exchange Bondholder Group (EBG)
Exchange Bondholder Group (EBG)
Brief for the United States of America As Amicus Curiae in support of the Republic of Argentina´s petition for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc submitted before the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
United States of America
United States of America
Brief for the United States of America As Amicus Curiae in support of reversal submitted before the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
United States of America
United States of America
Brief for non-party appelant the Bank of New York Mellon as indenture trustee
Bank of New York Mellon
Bank of New York Mellon
Close
How the Case Began
-
In 2001, after decades of over-indebtedness, and with the burden of a debt to GDP ratio of 166%, Argentina defaulted on its sovereign debt (US$81 billion), in the midst of the worst crisis in its history.
-
Since 2003, the governments of Nestor Kirchner and Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner, have moved forward in the process of normalizing the country’s financial obligations. The most challenging step was to restructure its debt with hundreds of bondholders under seven different currencies and multiple jurisdictions.
-
Argentina successfully restructured its debt with 92.4% of its bondholders (in 2005 and 2010). The offer was based on Argentina`s real payment capacity. By incorporating gross domestic product (GDP)-linked coupons, creditors became partners in the country’s prosperity.
-
However, a small minority of vulture funds chose not to join the debt exchange. These funds bought debt many years after the default and judicially harassed Argentina to obtain an exorbitant 1600% profit.
-
In a highly controversial decision, the US judicial system upheld the litigant’s request. Circumventing the sovereign immunities all nations have in the US, the ruling blocked 92.4% of Argentina’s exchange bondholders from collecting their payments until the litigants’ claims are fulfilled.
Close
Recent Action & Things To Watch For
“...the court grants plaintiffs' motions for specific performance. The Republic is ordered to specifically perform its obligations to plaintiffs under the pari passu clause by making ratable payments to plaintiffs any time it makes, or attempts to make, payments on the Exchange Bonds.”
United States District Court for the Southern District of New York
Opinion and Order of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York granting plaintiffs´motions for specific performance
October 30, 2015
“For the reasons stated by the Court of Appeals in its opinion on August 31, 2015, the court dismisses plaintiffs' Third Amended Complaint with prejudice.”
United States District Court for the Southern District of New York
Order of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissing plaintiffs´ Third Amended Complaint regarding alter ego allegations of Argentina´s central bank
“It is hereby declared, adjudged, and decreed in these actions that the Republic violated, and continues to violate, paragraph (1)(c) of the 1994 Fiscal Agency Agreement.”
United States District Court for the Southern District of New York
Opinion and Order of United States District Court for the Southern District of New York in the case captioned: “Trinity Investments Limited v. The Republic of Argentina” (case Nro. 15-cv-02611)
Close
-
“The injunction by its terms extends to virtually the entire global financial system.”
Peter Eavis
Reporter at The New York Times
Ruling on Argentina’s Debt May Give Creditors More Power
The New York Times
June 6, 2014
-
“The recent court rulings […] have very serious consequences that go far beyond Argentina.”
Nouriel Roubini
Teacher at New York University's Stern School of Business
Cofounder and Chairman of Roubini Global Economics
From Argentina to Greece: Crisis in the Global architecture of orderly sovereign debt restructurings
November 11, 2012
-
“The crisis in Europe is just the latest example of the high costs – for creditors and debtors alike – entailed by the absence of an international rule of law for resolving sovereign-debt crises”
Joseph Stiglitz
Nobel Laureate in Economics
Columbia University Professor
Former Chairman of President Bill Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisors
Former Senior Vice President and Chief Economist of the World Bank
Sovereign debt needs international supervision
The Guardian
June 6, 2015
-
“…In the course of this fight, the reputation of the United States as a reliable financial center has been damaged.”
Dan Rosenheck
Staff writer for The New Yorker
Former Argentina correspondent for The Economist
Argentina’s rational default
The New Yorker
August 8, 2014
-
“The declaration pointed to a new concern on vulture funds. Recent examples of the actions of vulture funds in international courts have revealed their highly speculative nature.”
Martin Khor
Executive Director of the South Centre
Board of directors of the International Forum on Globalization
G77 Declaration addresses “global challenges”
Third World Network
July 7, 2014
-
“Courts should not be bailing out distressed debt investment funds that choose to put their head in the mouth of the Leviathan. Investors are welcome to play that game, but it isn’t one the U.S. court system should play…”
Adam Levitin
Professor of Law at Georgetown University Law Center
The Examiners: Adam Levitin on Argentina and Distressed Investors
The Wall Street Journal
March 3, 2015
-
“In NML v. Argentina, the world continues to witness a rare una sureal spectacle: the unpredictable consequences unleashed by U.S. judge going rogue on the law”
Aldo Caliari
Director of Rethinking Bretton Woods Project at the Center of Concern
Where the Argentine Debt case Stands Now, and Why it still matters
NACLA
April 4, 2015
-
“The vultures have invoked the rule of law but we should be clear: This is about greed. […] By arguing for an interpretation of the legal principle that all investors be treated the same […] they have undermined the rule of law, and made debt restructuring almost impossible…”
Joseph Stiglitz
Nobel Laureate in Economics
Columbia University Professor
Former Chairman of President Bill Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisors
Former Senior Vice President and Chief Economist of the World Bank
A Global System is needed for debt restructuring
The New York Times
October 10, 2014
-
“The court's decision means that a vulture fund, or any "holdout" creditor, can prevent or destroy an existing agreement negotiated with the rest of the bondholders […], this would severely limit the ability […] to work out an orderly agreement…”
Mark Weisbrot
Co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR)
Who shot Argentina: a washington murder mistery
The Huffington Post
June 6, 2014
-
“…the case also raises questions about the politicization of the U.S. judicial system, in this unprecedented decision to force a default to creditors by a sovereign government that has both the intent and ability to pay…”
Eileen Appelbaum
Senior Economist at the Center for Economic and Policy Research
Visiting Professor in the Department of Management at the University of Leicester, UK
Debt Ruling Shows a Callous Disregard to the Effects on Argentina
The New York Times
September 9, 2014
-
“Elliott broke with long-standing international law and custom, according to which sovereign governments are not sued in regular courts meant to deal with questions internal to a nation state”
Saskia Sassen
Professor at Columbia University
Chairs The Committee on Global Thought
A short Story of vultures
Foreign Policy
August 8, 2014
-
“Singer has certainly earned his vulture feathers”
Greg Palast
Freelance journalist BBC
British newspaper The Guardian.
How Barack Obama could end the Argentina debt crisis
The Guardian
August 8, 2014
-
“Capitalism is not supposed to be a “heads I win, tails you lose” bet — but the Second Circuit Court’s decision would make it that way for sovereign debt bondholders.”
Mark Weisbrot
Co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR)
The Debt Vultures’ Fell Swoop
The New York Times
June 6, 2012
-
“But simple modifications like contract amendments will not overcome the system's deficiencies […] There is an urgent need to renew the United Nations' efforts to create a multinational legal framework for sovereign-debt restructuring…”
Joseph Stiglitz
Nobel Laureate in Economics
Columbia University Professor
Former Chairman of President Bill Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisors
Former Senior Vice President and Chief Economist of the World Bank
A Fair Hearing for Sovereign Debt
Project Syndicate
March 3, 2015
-
“The New York court decision is a precedent that prioritises the profits of financial speculators above the rights of a nation to make economical decisions and protect the interests of its people.”
Sarah-Jayne Clifton
Director of Jubilee Debt Campaign
Argentina is right to stand up to greedy US vultures
The Guardian
June 6, 2014
-
“So, rogue creditors need rogue courts, but when they do find them (as in this case) they make a good team don’t they ?”
Jorge Vilches
No vulture left behind
Counterpunch.org
October 10, 2014
-
“Argentina willingly pays its bondholders […] However holdout investors such as NML Capital which bought $50 million of Argentine distressed debt on the secondary markets are eyeing for super-profits of 1600 percent.”
Mark Bergfeld
Writer and activist based in Cologne, Germany and London, UK
Who is to blame for Argentina’s default
Russia Today
August 8, 2014
-
“In the Argentinian case, we are risking not just an end to Argentina's recovery but a fresh round of turmoil in the global financial market…”
Ha-Joon Chang
Fellow at the Center for Economic and Policy Research in Washington, D.C.
Serves on the Advisory Board of Academics Stand Against Poverty (ASAP)
How could Greece and Argentina—the new ‘debt colonies’—be set free?
The Guardian
November 11, 2012
-
“No sovereign government should be forced to accede to a handful of investors solely for the purpose of enriching those investors”
Zachary Karabell
American author
Historian
Economist
Doble default
Slate Magazine
August 8, 2014
-
“...the Griesa decision has opened up a Pandora’s box of trouble”
Conn Hallinan
Columnist for Foreign Policy
Independent journalist
Clintonians Join Vulture Flock Over Argentina
Thuthdig
July 7, 2015
-
“It was the first time in history that a country was willing and able to pay its creditors, but was blocked by a judge from doing so.”
Joseph Stiglitz
Nobel Laureate in Economics
Columbia University Professor
Former Chairman of President Bill Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisors
Former Senior Vice President and Chief Economist of the World Bank
Argentina’s Griesafault
Project Syndicate
August 8, 2014
-
“...We now have a glimpse of the sovereign debt world after Argentina. This world is fraught with uncertainty, perhaps more so than it has been since the early 1990s.”
Anna Gelpern
Nonresident senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics
Professor of law at Georgetown University
After Argentina
CreditSlips.org
June 6, 2014
-
“The repercussions of this miscarriage of justice may be felt for a long time […] what developing country […] will be prepared to issue bonds through the US financial system, when America’s courts […] seem to allow financial interests to trump the public interest?”
Joseph Stiglitz
Nobel Laureate in Economics
Columbia University Professor
Former Chairman of President Bill Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisors
Former Senior Vice President and Chief Economist of the World Bank
Vulture funds impede all debt restructuring
Shanghai Daily
September 9, 2013
-
“…a basic principle of modern capitalism—that when debtors cannot pay back creditors, a fresh start is needed—has been overturned.”
Joseph Stiglitz
Nobel Laureate in Economics
Columbia University Professor
Former Chairman of President Bill Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisors
Former Senior Vice President and Chief Economist of the World Bank
Vultures’ victory
Project Syndicate
September 9, 2013
-
“The US court decision is dangerous […] Holdouts must not be permitted to block orderly restructurings that benefit debtors and creditors.”
Nouriel Roubini
Teacher at New York University's Stern School of Business
Cofounder and Chairman of Roubini Global Economics
Gouging the Gauchos
January 1, 2014
-
“Judge Griesa’s “pari passu” interpretation has been hotly and widely contested worldwide, even in the US…”
Jorge Vilches
Argentina’s Default, Vulture Funds and the US Courts
Counterpunch.org
July 7, 2014
-
“What it is Argentina suffering due to american judicial hegemonism is worst than the absence of justice”
Thomas Piketty
Professor at the École des hautes études en sciences sociales (EHESS)
Professor at the Paris School of Economics
Interview: “What it is Argentina suffering due to american judicial hegemonism is worst than the absence of justice”
Pagina/12
November 11, 2014
-
“The danger lies in the longer term implications for sovereign debt management…”
John Weeks
Professor Emeritus at SOAS, University of London
Argentina will survive default but indebted nations in Africa will not be so lucky
August 8, 2014
-
“…[T]he Griesafault will carry a high price—less for Argentina than for the global economy and countries needing access to foreign financing.”
Joseph Stiglitz
Nobel Laureate in Economics
Columbia University Professor
Former Chairman of President Bill Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisors
Former Senior Vice President and Chief Economist of the World Bank
Argentina default? Griesafault is much more accurate
The Guardian
August 8, 2014
-
“A request must be made to the American judiciary that the money be released. That the decision of Judge Griesa be modified. […] Hold-ins have to thank for the availability and perdurability of the Argentine determination to pay.”
Tullio Zembo
Director of "L' italiano"
An eventual default of Argentina, I would call it induce default
July 7, 2014
-
“US Federal Judge Thomas P. Griesa’s ruling that Argentina must pay the vultures in full (after 93% of other bondholders agreed to a restructuring) will give free rein to opportunistic behaviors that sabotage future restructurings […] For the sake of a healthy global economy, the vultures must be grounded.”
Joseph Stiglitz
Nobel Laureate in Economics
Columbia University Professor
Former Chairman of President Bill Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisors
Former Senior Vice President and Chief Economist of the World Bank
Debeaking the vultures
Project Syndicate
October 10, 2014
-
“complexities arose that Judge Griesa seems not to have understood. […] the judge has a lot to think about. It would be better if he had done some of that thinking before he issued his order, or if the appeals court or the Supreme Court had forced him to do so.”
Floyd Norris
Chief financial correspondent of The New York Times
Chief financial correspondent of The International Herald Tribune
The Muddled Case of Argentine Bonds
The New York Times
July 7, 2014
-
“As described above, the Second Circuit’s opinion relies on an overly sanguine view of the efficacy of CACs, which conflicts with economic logic and evidence.”
Joseph Stiglitz
Nobel Laureate in Economics
Columbia University Professor
Former Chairman of President Bill Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisors
Former Senior Vice President and Chief Economist of the World Bank
Brief of Joseph Stiglitz as Amicus Curiae in support of the Republic of Argentina’s petition for a writ of certiorari
March 3, 2015
-
“Ms Fernández refers to the holdouts as “vultures”. This seems unfair to the birds. Vultures perform a valuable task. Holdouts do not recycle carrion but insist the carcass can meet its obligations—a strategy that can succeed only at the expense of those creditors who accept the reality that it cannot.”
Martin Wolf
Associate Editor and Chief Economics Commentator at the Financial Times
Holdouts give vultures a bad name
Financial Times
September 9, 2014
-
“…the case may end up being a lose-lose situation with significant economic costs for all parties involved, endless litigation and a disturbing precedent for international credit markets looking forward…”
Eduardo Levy Yeyati
President of the Board of CIPPEC
Director at Elypsis
Professor of Economics and Finance at the School of Economics of Universidad de Buenos Aires
Professor of Economics and Finance at the School of Business of Universidad Torcuato Di Tella
Visiting Professor of Public Policy at John F. Kennedy School of Government
A Costly, Lose-Lose Situation for Argentina and the Holdouts
The New York Times
August 8, 2014
-
“The International Monetary Fund, the news media and experts and politicians across the ideological spectrum have highlighted the dangerously mistaken and inconsistent interpretations made in Judge Griesa’s ruling.”
Alan B. Cibils
Chairman of the political economy department at the Universidad Nacional de General Sarmiento in Buenos Aires
In Argentina Debt Case, a Great Victory for Speculators
The New York Times
April 4, 2015
-
“The US judiciary, including its Supreme Court of Justice (SCOTUS), has been clearly ineffective regarding the Argentine case..”
Jorge Vilches
Did Argentina default?
The Independent International Political Research Center
January 1, 2015
-
“This brings us back to why the US Supreme Court decision will be closely watched. If the second circuit case is heard and upheld, then Argentina case makes it harder to undertake sovereign debt restructuring.”
Linda Yueh
Chief Business Correspondent and a Contributing Editor for BBC News
Why eurozone should monitor US Supreme Court decision on Argentina
BBC
January 1, 2014
-
“The Challenge by holdout creditors to the Argentine bond restructuring deal, if successful, would throw into question the feasibility of such contractual restructurings.”
José Antonio Ocampo
Professor of Professional Practice in International and Public Affairs at the School of International and Public Affairs, Columbia University
Director of the Economic and Political Development Concentration at the School of International and Public Affairs, Columbia University
Aldo Caliari
Director of Rethinking Bretton Woods Project at the Center of Concern
Argentina’s bondholders deserve their day in court
Financial Times
July 7, 2013
-
“All south american countries support Argentina. I support the fight of Cristina Kirchner”
Jacques Cheminade
President of Solidarity & Progress
Attack of vulture funds against Argentina—The dead can not repay their debts
JacquesCheminade.fr
April 4, 2015
-
“As a result of the ruling, a complicated issue is likely to become even more so.”
Anne Krueger
Professor of international economics at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies in Washington, D.C.
Former World Bank Chief Economist
Former First deputy managing director of the International Monetary Fund
Argentina`s Sovereign bondage
Project Syndicate
July 7, 2014
-
“"The majority of countries has become convinced both by experience and the force of the arguments ... that the private contractual approach, no matter how improved, won't solve the basic problem of sovereign debt restructuring. They are advocating for institutionalizing a multinational statutory solution, as reflected in the Resolution 68/304 passed by the General Assembly of the United Nations on September 9, 2014" ”
Joseph Stiglitz
Nobel Laureate in Economics
Columbia University Professor
Former Chairman of President Bill Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisors
Former Senior Vice President and Chief Economist of the World Bank
Martín Guzman
Postdoctoral research fellow at the Department of Economics and Finance at Columbia University Business School
Co-chair of the Columbia Initiative for Policy Dialogue Taskforce on Debt Restructuring and Sovereign Bankruptcy
Fixing Sovereign Debt Restructuring
July 7, 2015
-
“They failed to transfer the euro funds in accordance with their trust obligations […] Our interest payment is governed by U.K. law, which hasn’t ruled on this. Until there’s a similar injunction in the U.K., they owe us our interest payments.”
Kyle Bass
Founder and Principal of Hayman Capital Management, L.P.
Hayma’s Bass says Argentina Bond Trustee is failing investors
Bloomberg
August 8, 2014
-
“The District Court’s decision […] could cause unnecessary economic damage to the international financial system, as well as to U.S. economic interests, Argentina, and fifteen years of U.S. bi-partisan debt relief policy.”
Robert Solow
Recipient of John Bates Clark Medal
Nobel Laureate in Economics
Recipient of Presidential Medal of Freedom
Economists call on Congress to mitigate fallout from ruling on Argentine debt
July 7, 2014
-
“The last thing the financial world now needs is an unpredictable and uncertain sovereign debt market with rogue creditors supported by rogue courts.”
Jorge Vilches
The Trial of the Century?
Counterpunch.org
July 7, 2014
-
“ Now, for the first time in its history, the UN General Assembly has taken on a prominent role in international economic issues”
Saskia Sassen
Professor at Columbia University
Chairs The Committee on Global Thought
The Vultures of Wall Street
Boston Review
October 10, 2014
-
“Beyond the legal logic, however, the decision makes no economic sense…”
José Antonio Ocampo
Professor of Professional Practice in International and Public Affairs at the School of International and Public Affairs, Columbia University
Director of the Economic and Political Development Concentration at the School of International and Public Affairs, Columbia University
Implications of the US Supreme Court ruling on Argentina
Financial Times
June 6, 2014
-
“The ruling will make it more difficult for countries to free themselves from the burden of over-indebtedness. It will be very bad for international capital markets and it will also diminish national sovereignty.”
Felix Salmon
Senior Editor at Fusion
Finance blogger for Reuters
Former Financial journalist of Portfolio Magazine
Former Financial journalist of Euromoney
Hedge Fund v. Sovereign: How U.S. Courts are upending international finance
Foreign Affairs
April 4, 2015
-
“The international community should welcome the UN General Assembly's decision to launch negotiations on a multilateral framework for sovereign debt restructuring.”
José Antonio Ocampo
Professor of Professional Practice in International and Public Affairs at the School of International and Public Affairs, Columbia University
Director of the Economic and Political Development Concentration at the School of International and Public Affairs, Columbia University
The UN takes the first step to debt restructuring
Financial Times
September 9, 2014
-
“The crisis of capitalism, which dates back to 2008, caused a lot of countries to have extremely severe debts to pay; Argentina is seen as an example of how to get out of those situations…”
Emir Sader
Assistant professor at the State University of Rio de Janeiro, Laboratory Coordinator of Public Policy
Executive Secretary of the Consejo Latinoamericano de Ciencias Sociales
Vulture’s ability to subdue Argentina is at stake
Pagina/12
June 6, 2014
-
“The General Assembly could similarly draw up guidelines on how sovereign debt crises should de addressed ”
Barry Herman
Professor, Columbia University
Towards a Multilateral Framework for Recovery from Sovereign Insolvency
Initiative for Policy Dialogue
May 5, 2015
-
“…creditors should take responsibility for the risks they run”
Éric Toussaint
Spokesman for the Committee for the Abolition of Third World Debt (CADTM)
Joseph Stiglitz shows that a suspension of debt repayments can be beneficial for a country and its people
Committee for the Abolition of Third World Debt
January 1, 2015
-
“Judge Griesa´s novel 2012 pari passu ruling was unexpected, unprecedented and questioned by key international institutions.”
Samuel George
Project Manager at the Bertelsmann Foundation
Argentina: Holding up after holding out
August 8, 2014
-
“These consequences would be felt by debtor nations, creditors, the United States, and the international economy as a whole”
Anne Krueger
Professor of international economics at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies in Washington, D.C.
Former World Bank Chief Economist
Former First deputy managing director of the International Monetary Fund
Brief for Professor Anne Krueger as Amicus Curiae in Support of the Republic of Argentina and reversal
January 1, 2013
-
“Argentina is in the right side. It is a very difficult fight, but I am pleased that Argentina is fighting because what happened in US Courts does not make economic sense, it is not fair and it is an abuse”
Jeffrey Sachs
Director of The Earth Institute at Columbia University
Sachs on vulture funds: “It is an abuse US Court ruling”
Ambito Financiero
December 12, 2014
-
“…the case has set a legal precedent which has removed any incentive for investment funds to restructure the value of their bonds following default…”
Daniel Ozarow
Lecturer at Middlesex University
Convener at Argentina Research Network
Consultant and Trustee at Development, Evaluation, Research, Advice (DEVRA)
Let’s end this madness in the global debt system
Al Jazeera
August 8, 2014
-
“If Argentina is forced to pay holdouts in full, the price will be borne by Argentines. This is extortion backed by the U.S. judiciary”
Martin Wolf
Associate Editor and Chief Economics Commentator at the Financial Times
Defend Argentina from the vultures
Financial Times
June 6, 2014
-
“Griesa has shown no qualms in putting US law at the service of immoral parasitic “bankers and investors” such as Paul Singer of the Elliott/NML Fund and Mark Brodsky of the Aurelius Fund…”
Adrian Salbuchi
Sovereign debt for territory: A new global elite swap strategy
Russia Today
August 8, 2014

Speech by President Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner on UN Adoption of Principles on Sovereign Debt Restructuring Processes

G20 Leaders Endorse Actions Against Vulture Funds in Antalya Leaders Communiqué

Belgian court compels BoNY to deliver the European Bondholders´ funds frozen by Griesa

G24 Supports Steps to Address Holdout Behavior that Seriously Undermines Sovereign Debt Restructuring Processes

Vulture Funds target Puerto Rico: New Report by House Committee staff at US Congress

Kicillof at the UN: “This is a key step towards achieving a vulture free world”
